BH0/BH2 Laboratories Are Not the Same

[TheBatMan]

^ Now you bring up great points but it's done in such a dickish way which is only gonna add fuel to the fire.

But again you're absolutely right,

yet points news bot brings up to try and justify how it is indeed a different lab is also abslutely right minus one or two bits such as the geography which I mentioned.

It's just over looking into something that doesn't matter. Just enjoy the game and get on with it. I really don't get why people get so fired up and angry at each other over something which in the end is so trivial.

No one is angry, no one's being a dick. Just debating stuff in the games which is kind of the whole point of these forums. And its certainly not as weird as some of the crazies 1.5 brings up out of the woodwork.

[Aydan]

I guess maybe I'm reading it in a different tone, I'm so used to seeing people literally getting personal and typing sentences in a way to inflict anger and flaming just looks natural and you're absolutely right about the 1.5 stuff.

I'm just saying because when News Boy replies with 'Can't you even read/Don't bother replying' It's pretty much proving the point.

Anyways back onto the topic at hand

[News Bot]

The RPD in RE3 was actually a completely different RPD to RE2, it just looked the same.

Afterall, Nemesis broke that window in RE3, since RE2 was already made the developers knew they could not break that window, so for them to go an break it clearly means a different RPD or it just doesn't make sense. There was even a door that looked different in the RPD between RE2 and 3, and where was the gem puzzle. These bunch of differences are undeniable proof they are two different RPDs.

It isn't just poor consistency. The RE series has none of that.

Didn't you already pull your patented "leaving this thread nows!!!!" shtick? That would've saved you the embarrassment. Why don't you return to your previous argument about picking and choosing? But I'll go along with your logic. Let's see:

A single window.

VS:

Actually connected to a facility that exploded
Underneath a lake
An outbreak caused by the Queen Leech
A S.T.A.R.S. member walking right through
The Proto-Tyrant tearing through it (and somehow ending up at the treatment plant despite lacking the ability to use elevators)
A crumbled ceiling
A shutter with a massive hole in it courtesy of Proto-Tyrant
Hunters running around very close to a plant which employed 30% of Raccoon City
Connected to several facilities where outbreaks also occurred and B.O.W.s had spread from

Then we have a writer well-known for putting similar looking facilities throughout his works. Somehow he would never think to do that despite doing it a lot.

[Aydan]

Calm down now News Bot

Again you're points are absolutely rock solid. I guess with regards to the geography of the similar factory and where it is, I guess you just imagine it's there off camera somewhere, it's not like it matters anyway.

Thinking about it all I'd say that with your points it is a different place, but they did 1/1 recreations to just give a bit of a nudge to fans of Resident Evil 2. That'd be my best guess now. It does make more sense than it being exactly the same lab from RE2. However it does clash with some other bits, but at the end of the day it's a game, and it's a game in a series filled with loop holes and flaws which are linked together with a very loose glue haha

[Dracarys]

I guess maybe I'm reading it in a different tone

Well, I won't deny any sarcasm.



Also, someone needs learn the difference between not arguing and not posting, leave in peace means not turning into off topic argument. There are people who can discuss without arguing or insulting, I'll happily discuss with those.

[News Bot]

Also, someone needs learn the difference between not arguing and not posting. There are people who can discuss without arguing or insulting, I'll happily discuss with those.

Consistency not found.

I'll leave this thread in peace

Then you return to make some sarcasm-laden post aimed at making a very poor attempt to undermine me. That isn't very far off from arguing. Then you'll likely reply to this again, and be in an argument. You've already made a fool of yourself, so there's no real need to address you anymore since you've got nothing new to bring to the table.

EDIT: And more sources.

Deep within this factory that was infested with zombies and even stronger biological weapons, I met up once again with Enrico, Bravo Team's commander. Somehow, some of Bravo Team had managed to survive. On the other side of the factory was a mansion.

Somehow you could reach the mansion by going through the areas in BH2 and Outbreak, eh?

[Carnivol]

Guy(s) and girl(s), stay civilized now. Don't kill eachother (or make others do it for you). I hate to start my big important week with blood.

[AsteroidBlues]

Guy(s) and girl(s), stay civilized now. Don't kill eachother (or make others do it for you). I hate to start my big important week with blood.

Pfftt, that's the best way to start a week Carn. We both know that. Seriously though, why can't we just accept News Bot's overwhelmingly logical and factually supported theory versus "Nuh-uh!" and move on? I mean, how masochistic can you be to get slapped (hard) with supporting evidence only to come back and get slapped with more?

Also, need I remind people that we're talking about a set of video games? Ones that are over a decade old? Why can't it be a peaceful discussion thread instead of a virtual pissing match all the time? xD

[News Bot]

Why can't it be a peaceful discussion thread instead of a virtual pissing match all the time? xD

You haven't read most of my topics, have you? There are usual suspects that desperately want me to be wrong but never have the ability to prove it. It usually doesn't matter how much sources you present to them as their main tactic is to outright ignore them. I can mention at least six different topics where it's the exact same story.

That said, here in particular, there are several people who have made very good points.

[Dracarys]

Pfftt, that's the best way to start a week Carn. We both know that. Seriously though, why can't we just accept News Bot's overwhelmingly logical and factually supported theory versus "Nuh-uh!" and move on? I mean, how masochistic can you be to get slapped (hard) with supporting evidence only to come back and get slapped with more?

Also, need I remind people that we're talking about a set of video games? Ones that are over a decade old? Why can't it be a peaceful discussion thread instead of a virtual pissing match all the time? xD

You've got brown on your nose.

[RaccoonSurvivor]

^ Ewww haha

As for the whole ''why can't you get to the mansion in RE2 and Outbreak? Well, cause Capcom simply didn't want you to get there. It's that simple.
Game developers do it all the time with invisible walls and such to stop you going ''beyond'' the level.
Not to mention the mansion is right next to the Training Facility (in Zero's FMV ending and the novel)
I mean, hey , Enrico had a whole DAY to walk there anyway right? hehe .. Jill and Barry find him in the Underground mid way through RE1 - we never see him since Rebecca sees him in Zero and when STARS meet him later on..

Again, people can believe what they want to, but I wish people wouldn't force their opinions on others as if they're 100% facts - maybe a little, but nothing with Capcom has ever been concrete

[News Bot]

It goes beyond "why can't you get to the mansion."

We visibly see that the mansion is in the middle of the forest and both S.T.A.R.S. teams had to take a helicopter to get to it. It is not right next to the city. And even if it were, its explosion would've been quite visible. The only reason it was actually noticed unlike the training facility and treatment plant is because it caused a large fire. On top of that, Enrico still manages to get to the mansion despite being in a lab beneath the city, and despite not going Rebecca's route which actually DOES take her to right outside the mansion. Enrico goes the same route we all did in BH2.

This would all mean that Birkin's facility was exposed to like five separate outbreaks. That's ridiculous.

[Lanzagranadas]

Well, most people will be stucked in their own point of view as normally happens.

Time and space issues between different games coexisting in the same region, that´s something that doesn´t happen now since every new game uses a brand new set of locations.

Sadly nobody can ask N. Sugimura, writter from RE0 and RE2, he could had provided the final answer to this.