IGN - "The Best Resident Evil?"

[Umon Daisuke]

For RE DS, RE2 DC and RE1 Saturn I used VgCharz
As Claren already pointed out PC didn't really impact sales so much, they're irrelevant, and unfortunately i can't find RE2 N64 sales data, sorry but I'm sure considering the N64 RE2 sold better than RE1

350K in the US according to the NPD.. but let's just say it totaled 500K worldwide since the N64 was pretty much a dead cause in Japan and Europe.

Every bit counts, so the belated DC and GC ports would've added a small chunk as well to the totals.

[Skunky]

Can one of you wise guys make up a new list of all the game's totals, please?
(like I tried on the other thread but with more and newer sales data)
It would actually make an interesting sticky topic and could be edited when new data becomes available.

Could even include a fancy graph... they always look nice.

[Sunglasses]

So if we consider RE2 Dreamcast and GC sales data we have to consider also RE DS and REbirth (GC and Wii) sales data? or not?

[Vector]

This current dispute is going nowhere fast.

[Sunglasses]

Ok RE2 sold a bit more than RE1, case closed... But I still prefer RE1

[Skunky]

REmake/REbirth is a separate thing IMO.
But Deadly Silence is close enough to the original (with some adjustments) to be considered a port (IMO) and therefore could be included in the overall RE1 sales.

[Bertha]

This current dispute is going nowhere fast.

Agreed. Just because one game sells more than another doesn't make it the best game.

[Skunky]

Agreed. Just because one game sells more than another doesn't make it the best game.

I agree!
But the sales figures are interesting. I guess we're going off topic...

[Vector]

Here, this should help us get back on topic:

RE4 WAS TEH BESTEZT SURVIVOL HORRA GAME EVUR BCUZ OVEN MAN MADE ME PEWP MY PENTZ LOLOLOOL

[Bertha]

Here, this should help us get back on topic:

RE4 WAS TEH BESTEZT SURVIVOL HORRA GAME EVUR BCUZ OVEN MAN MADE ME PEWP MY PENTZ LOLOLOOL

BUT IT LACKS TEH JILLZ OMG NO WAI IT SUX LEON'S GAI!!11

In reality...sales figures only mean so much. They don't account for if the game is enjoyable or not. Would you say that just because one of the movies grossed so much that it is brilliant? Don't think so.

[Vector]

In reality...sales figures only mean so much. They don't account for if the game is enjoyable or not. Would you say that just because one of the movies grossed so much that it is brilliant? Don't think so.

If we're going by sales...
The best album of all-time is Michael Jackson's Thriller.
The best movie of all-time is Titanic.
The best game of all-time is Super Mario Bros.


...oh wait, what are those, opinions?

Right, I forgot.

[Umon Daisuke]

That really wasn't a dispute, just a fact check. Sales don't account to quality most of the time, but there are exceptions as few as they may be.

The MK games last gen. ended up being the best selling fighter alongside the DBZ ones, outselling the likes of TTT, T5 and the two versions of VF4. They certainly weren't quality games as there hasn't been a decent MK since 1996.

[missvalentine]

oh i love discussing sales.

RE1 was on the PS1, PC, and the Sega Saturn, so it must of made some money from that as well, and RE DS certainly does count.

also it must have sold something on the PSN as well, anyways, there both neck and neck, but im hoping RE1 comes out on top.

anyways, opinion polls are always wrong anyway, most of IGN probably have never even played a classic RE game.

[Rakkoon]

I don't know about the rest of you, but I loved the water puzzle in RE3. It was just fun to try and figure out, and very rewarding when you did. We need more puzzles like that in the series, something that isn't frustrating as such but is actually quite fun to do.

My favorite puzzle of all times. I also liked the music box one.

[News Bot]

and RE DS certainly does count.

RE: DS is more or less a new game entirely, just like REmake. It's not counted under sales figures with RE1 unless you're extremely pissy for whatever reason. It's a seperate title altogether.

RE2 sold more, you cannot argue this. Take into account that RE2 also had PS1 re-releases that aren't even counted in Capcom's figure graph. Dual Shock comes to mind. Then there's the PC releases (RE2 sold pretty well on the PC in comparison to RE1), Dreamcast and Gamecube. The Capcom figure is taken from the first print edition of the PS1 version alone.

Agreed. Just because one game sells more than another doesn't make it the best game.

This "dispute" isn't about the quality of the games. It's just a fact-war.