RE4 vs. RE5: Voice-Acting

[Darkmoon]

Capcom didn't make the movies, and therefore they cannot be considered canon. Capcom did make Umbrella Chronicles, and while it's a safe bet that you can ignore the new version of the older scenarios as cliff notes versions of the old games the new scenarios and information have to be considered canon until proven otherwise...and no, sadly, being inspired by those shitty movies doesn't count or RE4 wouldn't be canon.

Give that it was confirmed in RE5 then it has to be considered canon. Now, you can choose to ignore it. I know one guy refuses to acknowladge anything RE4 and after is canon. That doesn't actually make it so, of course. But it made him feel better. And unfortunately that means that Red Queen is officially in the game and was under Wesker's control.

[adamthegrave]

Capcom didn't make the movies, and therefore they cannot be considered canon. Capcom did make Umbrella Chronicles, and while it's a safe bet that you can ignore the new version of the older scenarios as cliff notes versions of the old games the new scenarios and information have to be considered canon until proven otherwise...and no, sadly, being inspired by those shitty movies doesn't count or RE4 wouldn't be canon.

Give that it was confirmed in RE5 then it has to be considered canon. Now, you can choose to ignore it. I know one guy refuses to acknowladge anything RE4 and after is canon. That doesn't actually make it so, of course. But it made him feel better. And unfortunately that means that Red Queen is officially in the game and was under Wesker's control.

dude the red queen is not the Real Cannons of Re-games Again RE:uc was just a game for people who had not play any Re games it was for people understand the story right and what they did was if who SAW the movie right and thought let make it easy for people to understand is going on in RE-games
story! there you go, Now if u played the RE-game from Classic up to RE5 those are cannons and u understood the story & you know that red queen isnt in REAL Cannons of re-games. so why half of the people are just FANS of the movies WANTS to believe that Red queen cause there a FAN of the Red Queen. and capcom doesnt not care what cannons or not they want your money.

[Darkmoon]

...dear God, you ave no idea how much you insulted me by infering I'm a fan of those movies. I despise them. They are awful, just fucking awful.

Just for clairty's sake...I played RE for the first time somewhat before its release date. Trust me when I say I know the story pretty well. And yes, the versions of the older games were to show the newer fans what they'd missed out on, especially with then Chris and Wesker stuff. But the new scenarios are canon. Capcom didn't make them for amusement value, and if it was simply to show new fans what was missing they wouldn't have added those scenarios.

The additional scenarios, the ones that featured the Red Queen, Sergie and such were canon. They weren't just added for amusement, I'm afraid. They happened. We know this thanks to RE5

So you have two options. Either Umbrella Chronicles AND Resident Evil 5 are both not canon or they both are. Since UC is refered to in RE5's files there can be no doubt of this. I'm sorry, that's just how it is.

[Mr_Zombie]

Red queen was not or EVER in the Re games this aint no like or not.

Yes it was. The game's name is Umbrella Chronicles. >_>
It's a game. Made by Capcom. The story from it is mentioned in RE5, thus we are to believe it happened for real in RE universe (unlike, for example, Gaiden). What don't you understand here?

You can't compare this to movies, written by Anderson, which only used few of Resident Evil characters and monsters and contradicted RE (games) stories in every single way.

And I'm with Darkmoon here - I didn't like Anderson's movies (although I think the first one was so so as an action-"horror" movie) and I'm not including Red Queen (Umbrella's system, not some weird AI with homicidal intentions) because I'm fan of it, but because it was in a game.

[missvalentine]

i think RE5 has the better voice acting, but only by a little bit.

[adamthegrave]

Yes it was. The game's name is Umbrella Chronicles. >_>
It's a game. Made by Capcom. The story from it is mentioned in RE5, thus we are to believe it happened for real in RE universe (unlike, for example, Gaiden). What don't you understand here?

You can't compare this to movies, written by Anderson, which only used few of Resident Evil characters and monsters and contradicted RE (games) stories in every single way.

And I'm with Darkmoon here - I didn't like Anderson's movies (although I think the first one was so so as an action-"horror" movie) and I'm not including Red Queen (Umbrella's system, not some weird AI with homicidal intentions) because I'm fan of it, but because it was in a game.

so is Alice in the game too if ur saying red queen is, for i DONT understand is that why do yal think the red queen is in the games ?
which it isnt just because the movie & game of RE:UC came out doesnt say "oh i quess the red queen is in the game!" thats dumb. And Gaiden is a story that never came about. and again RE:uc was & is a filler so cant u get that?

[BadWolfX]

What are you talking about? The Red Queen is in the Umbrella Chronicles. It's fact.

Although I can't understand half the post so I'm not really sure what you're opinion is or what you're actually talking about. All I could draw from it is that you, for some reason, think the RQ is in UC, which she is.

[adamthegrave]

What are you talking about? The Red Queen is in the Umbrella Chronicles. It's fact.

Although I can't understand half the post so I'm not really sure what you're opinion is or what you're actually talking about. All I could draw from it is that you, for some reason, think the RQ is in UC, which she is.

iknow its in the RE:UC show me thats she in any other video games please! show me if its in Re1 - re5 do they even talk about her in other video games??? sadly thats a no
and what im talking about fillers & red queen
im looking threw the history of RE in re5 nope red queen or saids nothing about it. if i did it would say ha

[Alexia_Ashford]

Adam, you obviously know nothing about the games. People aren't "assuming" the Red Queen is in the games, she is. The red and white Queen for that matter.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-qYpGrZTdOw

Watch this and be enlightened.

[Bertha]

Adam, you obviously know nothing about the games. People aren't "assuming" the Red Queen is in the games, she is. The red and white Queen for that matter.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-qYpGrZTdOw

Watch this and be enlightened.

Sadly Alexia, that won't hold any value to him because it is from UC.

[adamthegrave]

[QUOTE=Alexia_Ashford;98499]Adam, you obviously know nothing about the games. People aren't "assuming" the Red Queen is in the games, she is. The red and white Queen for that matter.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-qYpGrZTdOw

Watch this and be enlightened.[/QUOTE

AGAIN its UMBRELLA Chronicles (filler) if had wouldnt it be told in re5 in the history? duh and i dont understand the games lol , please its seems that u cant understand was a filller or not. go get ur book of archives book and start RE-reading it noob and have a nice day! if ur a well whatever you call yourself go back re-play the direct Re-games from 1- 5 and come back tell me what happens please if u know so much of RE-stuff. please tell ill be waiting

wth ru talking Mist? value? please i dont need no value from RE:uc (filler)

[Bertha]

AGAIN its UMBRELLA Chronicles (filler) if had wouldnt it be told in re5 in the history? duh and i dont understand the games lol , please its seems that u cant understand was a filller or not. go get ur book of archives book and start RE-reading it noob and have a nice day!

wth ru talking Mist?

No one was arguing if it was a filler or not. The question was about whether or not it was canon. Which it is. Just because something is a filler doesn't mean it isn't canon. And please...try to use a bit better grammar and be a little less rude to other members. Calling a well respected member of the community like Alexia a noob is not a very smart thing to do.

[Vector]

Adam, you obviously know nothing about the games. People aren't "assuming" the Red Queen is in the games, she is. The red and white Queen for that matter.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-qYpGrZTdOw

Watch this and be enlightened.

AGAIN its UMBRELLA Chronicles (filler) if had wouldnt it be told in re5 in the history? duh and i dont understand the games lol , please its seems that u cant understand was a filller or not. go get ur book of archives book and start RE-reading it noob and have a nice day!

Okay Adam, between struggling to read your horrendous internet dialect and reporting you for that cute little insult you added in at the end, I just had to laugh. People really need to get off of this "I don't like it so it's not canon" bandwagon, or "filler this" and "filler that." Do you think Capcom really cares that you don't like the game?

"adamthegrave doesn't like it, guys...it's not canon."

wth ru talking Mist?

I'm pretty sure you just proved exactly 'wth' she was 'talking.'

[adamthegrave]

Okay Adam, between struggling to read your horrendous internet dialect and reporting you for that cute little insult you added in at the end, I just had to laugh. People really need to get off of this "I don't like it so it's not canon" bandwagon, or "filler this" and "filler that." Do you think Capcom really cares that you don't like the game?

"adamthegrave doesn't like it, guys...it's not canon."



I'm pretty sure you just proved exactly 'wth' she was 'talking.'

i really dont care say i mean its board site so yea well. so yal getting all mad for nothing how is that a freaking insult ? i just go read ur books what!? hahaha lol losers 4 think RE:UC is a cannon

[Darkmoon]

1 - Something is canon if it happened in the game universe.

2 - Something is filler if it's a short and easy game.

Umbrella Chronicles is both. Filler can be canon. Show me one place where it says Umbrella Chronicles is not canon. You won't be able to do it. And I can prove, in the game universe, that the events in Umbrella Chronicles took place. Therefore the Red and White Queens are both canon...just as the fact Wesker took down Umbrella itself, just as the fact that TALOS existed. Etc.

Umbrella Chronicles is filler, as you describe it. Fine. So is Survivor. Are you telling me that despite being mentioned in the introduction to RE0 that Survivor isn't canon as well? Or maybe CODE: Veronica isn't canon. After all, it's not a numbered game. It must be filler, and not canon. Wesker just magically returned from his grave with no explanation.