Silent Hill 2 Tenth Anniversary

[Darkmoon]

Max Payne or Torment takes the cake for narrative crown, in my opinion. Even if Silent Hill 2 has one of the most memorable characters in gaming, and a damn fine game and the best Silent Hill title. You be thinking with a bias mind ;)

Ironically, I have both games and have yet to play either. So Silent Hill 2 is still getting my vote. Maybe once I get around to playing them...

[america>europe]

Max Payne or Torment takes the cake for narrative crown, in my opinion. Even if Silent Hill 2 has one of the most memorable characters in gaming, and a damn fine game and the best Silent Hill title. You be thinking with a bias mind ;)

>Max Payne

pfffffhahahahahahahahahaha

your opinion is bad and you should feel bad.

[Zombie Fred]

>Max Payne

pfffffhahahahahahahahahaha

your opinion is bad and you should feel bad.

There was no glory in this. I hadn't asked for this crap. Trouble had come to me, in big dark swarms. The good and the just, they were like gold dust in this city. I had no illusions. I was not one of them. I was no hero. Just me and the gun, and the crook. My options had decreased to a singular course.

Spoiler:

show spoiler

[Mr. Spencer]

>Max Payne

pfffffhahahahahahahahahaha

your opinion is bad and you should feel bad.

The first thing you should know about us is, we have people everywhere.

[Archelon]

If we're talking about writing, my vote goes to the Legacy of Kain series. Leagues better voice acting, too.

[DarkMemories]

Since I judge narrative crown on the ability to tell an epic story without detriment to its integrity as a game, my vote goes for either Mass Effect or Uncharted on that point.

Still, SH2 is a fantastic game and it's a strange feeling knowing it's already ten years old. Happy anniversary.

[Darkmoon]

....again, I've just acquired Blood Omen and Soul Reaver to start playing through the series. What is it with all these games I've yet to play apparently being awesome?

[Archelon]

The Legacy of Kain series, in my opinion, has one of the best narratives in gaming history. The writing is top notch, probably the closest we'll ever get to a Shakespearean play in video game form.

Amy Hennig, who writes the Uncharted series, also wrote the LoK series, so that should give you an idea. The difference being that while the writing in the Uncharted games is excellent, the actual stories are pretty ho hum. The LoK games actually require you to think.

I would also like to say that the only time I've ever gotten choked up by a game was during a certain scene in Defiance. It was one of the few times I was really caught off guard by a game's story.

[Darkmoon]

Like the sound of that. If I wasn't balls deep in stuff I really wanna play and only a few hours a week to play them in...

[Mr. Spencer]

I'm going to mention the Syphon Filter series, as it's a narrative that actually makes sense and flows well from one game to the next.

Plus it's written by John Garvin.

[PracticalAl]

Let's not all forget Deadly Premonition either. ♥

[GuardhouseMusic]

Let's not all forget Deadly Premonition either. ♥

Yes, it'd go down in history, if it wasn't such a rip-off of a pre-existing work. Same goes for SNATCHER, though that's more of a pastiche, anyway.

Nonetheless, I'd definitely give SH2 the narrative crown, if I could give the characterization crown to SH3.

[Smiley]

I went over to my friend's house and watched him beat it last night. Leave ending. Needless to say he looked like he had a rough night of sleeping when I saw him this morning.

[I_Am_Nemesis]

I bought this years ago and never really completed it, maybe because just scared the shit out of me.....anyways I left it for years and I decided to replay it after seeing this post and the damn thing didnt work, it worked right up until I got into the hospital then just froze! seriously annoying.

[REmaster]

The Legacy of Kain series, in my opinion, has one of the best narratives in gaming history. The writing is top notch, probably the closest we'll ever get to a Shakespearean play in video game form.

Amy Hennig, who writes the Uncharted series, also wrote the LoK series, so that should give you an idea. The difference being that while the writing in the Uncharted games is excellent, the actual stories are pretty ho hum. The LoK games actually require you to think.

I would also like to say that the only time I've ever gotten choked up by a game was during a certain scene in Defiance. It was one of the few times I was really caught off guard by a game's story.

I didn't think anyone else on here liked LOK

You're absolutely right, the narrative is truly amazing. My old sig was from a quote from defiance that I found very moving. The series has received a lot of flak for not having the best game play, but that's when the superb story telling comes in. The voice acting is some of the best I've ever heard, especially from Kain. I wish they'd make another one, but alas the plot is all wrapped up. I guess that's never stopped anyone before though.

"One can only match, move by move, the machinations of fate... and thus defy the tyrannous stars." - Kain

Anyways, Happy B-day SH2.